Exploring the Groundbreaking Case of China First Virtual Digital Human IP Dispute: Insights and Industry Impact

Recently, the Beijing Internet Court delivered its first-instance verdict in China inaugural copyright infringement case related to virtual digital humans. This groundbreaking ruling marks a significant step forward in protecting intellectual property rights for digital humans in China. It provides crucial legal clarity for international companies involved in virtual digital human projects within the Chinese market and offers valuable insights for the global digital content industry. The case involves virtual digital humans A and B, jointly created by Company J and Company Y. Their images were sold without authorization by a former employee, Sun, on a CG model platform. It represents China first judicial review of ownership and infringement issues concerning intellectual property rights in virtual digital humans. Case Background and Key Issues Virtual digital humans A and B were jointly developed by four organizations, including Company J and Company Y. Company J retains the copyright, while Company Y manages

Read More »

Rising Refusal Rates for Trademark Applications in China: Insights into Changing Examination Standards and Strategic Considerations

Understanding CNIPA Stricter Trademark Examination Policies and Their Impact on Brands From 2024, the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA), which oversees the Trademark Office (TMO) and the Trademark Review and Adjudication Board (TRAB), introduced significantly stricter examination criteria for new trademark applications. This policy change has led to a notable increase in refusals based on absolute grounds, as well as more frequent objections citing prior trademarks. This rigorous approach reflects CNIPA goal to reduce the annual number of trademark registrations in China, thereby strengthening the quality and distinctiveness of the trademark register. Since these enhanced standards were implemented, brand owners have faced a growing number of refusals that sometimes seem arbitrary or inconsistent with past practices. Particularly challenging are cases where applicants already hold valid registrations for identical textual marks in China and seek to protect new stylized versions of the same marks. Such refusals not only hinder brand

Read More »

Triumph in Court: How Trademark Prior Use Won the Day in a Landmark Infringement Battle

Case Notes: A Landmark Victory in Prior Use Trademark Defense In the summer of 2024, an urgent matter interrupted my routine work. Zhejiang MEEC Company, a reputable enterprise with nearly 20 years in the electroplating industry, faced a significant trademark infringement lawsuit. A Beijing-based company, holding the registered MEEC trademark, claimed damages of US$10Million, threatening the longstanding reputation that Zhejiang MEEC had built over two decades. Reviewing the case files took me back to 1997, when our client first began using the MEEC name on their electroplating products. The plaintiff acquired the MEEC word and graphic trademarks by assignment in 2013 and promptly initiated litigation. This was a clear example of trademark squatting and opportunistic litigation, which often prevailed under the judicial environment at that time. The courtroom proceedings resembled a silent battle. Our initial evidence included product containers from 1999, preserved over the years. Judicial appraisal confirmed these items

Read More »
Andrea_liang

Overview of Challenges and Solutions in IP Protection of Furniture Design

In the world of upholstered furniture, crafting pieces with unique flair hinges not just on premium materials like leather and fabric, but also on the artistry embedded in detailed design blueprints. Yet, amid fierce battles in the raw materials arena, some suppliers take a darker path—snatching original design sketches without permission. These stolen designs are then handed out to furniture makers, sometimes for free or at bargain prices, fueling a shadow market of pirated furniture styles. This cunning move boosts their leather and fabric sales while lining their pockets unfairly. Interestingly, it’s often the material suppliers, rather than the furniture creators themselves, who dive deepest into these infringement waters. Their unauthorized copying and spreading of design plans not only trample on patents but also fan the flames of furniture piracy across the industry. The widespread piracy by material suppliers in China considerably restricts the market space for original designs. Designers

Read More »
Contract Disputes
Andrea_liang

Navigating Contract Disputes in China: Lessons from an International Buyer’s Experience

For international buyers operating in China, contract disputes present unique challenges that require careful navigation of the local legal landscape. Our recent experience with a breach of contract case offers valuable insights into this complex process. Overview of the Breach of Contract Case While we always strive to work with dependable and responsible suppliers, sometimes challenges arise. This became clear when we placed an order with a new factory for CNC machining of 6-meter-long aluminum profiles. Initially, everything seemed promising: samples were approved, a trial order was halfway completed, and the factory appeared responsive and diligent. It looked like the beginning of a strong partnership—until we placed the full-scale order. Machining these long profiles was particularly demanding, as we required flawless surfaces without scratches or blemishes—a standard we later slightly relaxed to accommodate feasibility. This necessitated careful post-machining inspections, especially since raw materials occasionally arrived with imperfections that the factory

Read More »

Chinese brands broadening horizons through international purchases

In recent years, an increasing number of Chinese brands have confidently entered the international market by acquiring well-known foreign brands. Today, renowned names such as Arc’teryx, G-III, Paladin, Bogner, and THG—previously celebrated worldwide—are now proudly included in the portfolios of Chinese companies. These brands have been integrated into a strategic framework developed by Chinese enterprises, highlighting the rich and diverse appeal of Chinese branding on the global stage. Intellectual property, as a crucial asset for maintaining competitive advantage, has become a fundamental element in China overseas acquisition strategies. By carefully assessing risks and aiming to maximize the protection and acquisition of their rights, Chinese companies are effectively managing the transfer, restructuring, and value enhancement of intellectual property associated with these international brands. As Chinese brands continue to globalize, many companies have strategically prioritized acquiring overseas brands. Since 2019, despite a slowdown caused by the pandemic, over 20 acquisitions of foreign

Read More »

Trademark Battles Among Business Partners: Who Truly Owns trademark Rights to Barizam?

The Supreme Court delivered a final decision regarding the trademark ownership and infringement dispute between Heilongjiang Chuanfeng Co and Russia Balizam concerning the Barizam trademarks. The Court overturned the previous rulings from the lower courts, affirming that the Barizam series trademarks registered in China rightfully belong to Russia Barizamm Company, and has ordered the transfer of these trademarks accordingly. This case, arising from a dispute between Chinese and foreign partners, centers on determining trademark ownership following the dissolution of their cooperation. It provides valuable guidance for many joint ventures and cooperative enterprises in China. Notably, this marks the Supreme Court first ruling requiring the transfer of trademarks to its legitimate owner in response to malicious trademark squatting. Judgement Initial Cooperation and Market Entry Heilongjiang Chuanfeng Co., Ltd., an import-export company specializing in border trade, discovered the popular Russian alcoholic brand Balizam, produced by Balizam Open Joint Stock Company of Ussuriysk

Read More »
Andrea_liang

Why Chinese Companies Are Taking Their Rival Firms to Court on Foreign Soil

On June 12, 2025, a spokesperson from the Munich District Court in Germany confirmed that Datang Mobile had initiated three patent infringement lawsuits against Xiaomi in a German court. The patents involved—EP2237607 (method and apparatus for cell handover), EP3713313 (uplink power control method and mobile communication terminal), and EP2315369 (method and apparatus for adaptive modulation and coding)—are fundamental to LTE/4G technology and play a significant role in the advancement of 5G technology. Background and Context of Overseas Patent Disputes Among Chinese Companies This case is part of a broader trend rather than an isolated incident. For example, in 2024, Lenovo filed a lawsuit against ZTE in the UK concerning licensing fees, which sparked considerable discussion within China. In recent years, the frequency of Chinese companies litigating against each other in foreign jurisdictions has increased, drawing widespread attention. Several factors contribute to this development, including legal environment considerations, market strategies, competitive

Read More »

The MUJI Trademark Wars: 24 Years of Legal Battles and Implications for Foreign Brands in China

Introduction: Navigating a Commercial Paradox in China Retail Landscape In the bustling shopping centers of Shanghai and Beijing, consumers witness a unique intellectual property scenario unfolding firsthand. Two separate companies operate stores under the identical MUJI brand—Japan Ryohin Keikaku Co., Ltd. (Authentic MUJI) and Beijing Cottonfield Textile Co., Ltd. (Chinese MUJI)—located just meters apart yet entirely independent. In July 2025, the Supreme Court landmark ruling affirming Beijing Cottonfield Class 24 无印良品 trademark right (covering towels, textiles, and bedding) concludes a 24-year legal battle and highlights key insights into China evolving IP environment. The Japanese MUJI brand journey in China sets important precedents for international brands navigating China first-to-file trademark system, illustrating both the risks of delayed registration and the legal framework enabling brand coexistence. Overview of the complex 无印良品 Trademark Procedures The trademark conflict between two MUJIs over the “MUJI” trademark has spanned 24 years, involving three key stages: opposition,

Read More »
evidence burden
Andrea_liang

The Rising Tide of TOPCon Patent Wars: How China’s Solar Giants Battling for Technological Supremacy

Introduction: The New Frontier of Solar Innovation The global photovoltaic industry stands at a critical inflection point in late 2024. As nations accelerate renewable energy adoption, a technological arms race has erupted among China’s solar titans – Trina Solar, Canadian Solar, JinkoSolar, LONGi Energy, and JA Solar. At the heart of this conflict lies TOPCon (Tunnel Oxide Passivated Contact) solar technology, the breakthrough cell architecture achieving record-breaking efficiencies exceeding 24%. Unlike previous solar patent skirmishes, these battles span continents and involve unprecedented financial stakes, with single lawsuits now exceeding $150 million in claims. This high-stakes competition reflects the fundamental strategic value of TOPCon technology: its seamless compatibility with existing production lines offers manufacturers a rare combination of performance enhancement without revolutionary retooling costs. The resulting concentration of patent warfare surrounding TOPCon innovations has transformed corporate boardrooms into war rooms and factory floors into intellectual property battlegrounds. Section 1: Anatomy of

Read More »

Subscribed

Recent Posts
Newsletter Signup Form
Hello, and thank you for your interest. Please be advised that this website is independently operated and managed by me personally, and all content is authored by myself. Due to the constraints of a one-person operation, my responses to subscription messages may occasionally be delayed. I appreciate your understanding. If you are interested in the content on this site, I encourage you to contact me directly via email wenwen82cn@vip.163.com. I will ensure that you receive the latest articles directly to your inbox as soon as they are published.